I never expected an island name to get a product listing removed. Alongside the wall decals we print, we also make wallpaper. While researching the market in 2019, I noticed demand for searches related to Martinique in the Caribbean. Its large leaves and vines inspired me to create tropical wallpaper for people who had visited the island or simply loved that look.
The plan seemed simple. Use the name of a popular place in the title and tags so buyers could find our product. We were not using AI then, so I asked a designer to draw large leaves and vines as vector artwork. That meant we could scale the image to different walls without losing quality. We called the jungle design Martinique Nature Wallpaper and listed it on Etsy.
In 2020, an unexpected email arrived from Etsy. Our listing had been removed following a trademark complaint. I was shocked because, to me, Martinique was just the name of an island. Until then, I thought only governments could hold rights to the names of countries and cities.
I started looking into it and realised I was wrong. Martinique is a French overseas department, but the complaint concerned a US trademark for wall coverings. The name was connected to the famous banana leaf pattern created in the previous century and used at the Beverly Hills Hotel. Our vector artwork was drawn from scratch and the leaves were different. However, the complaint concerned the word in our listing title.
I found the contact details of Katy, the head of the company that owned the rights. I wrote a polite email, explained that we had not known about the trademark, apologised and immediately removed Martinique from the listing. Katy replied calmly and clearly. She did not object to us listing the product again without that word and suggested forwarding her email to Etsy.
I happily sent the exchange to Etsy's legal department and received a refusal. Etsy did not accept forwarded emails. The rights owner had to contact Etsy directly and formally withdraw the complaint. Her agreement in our conversation was not enough.
I had to write to Katy again. I apologised for contacting her a second time and asked her to send Etsy a separate email. She said she would, and she did help. A couple of days later, Etsy confirmed that the complaint had been withdrawn and we could restore our listing.
This was one of the few intellectual property disputes in my experience that ended peacefully and without extra payments. An ordinary conversation with the person representing the brand made the difference. The lesson stayed with me. Even a familiar place name is worth checking before using it in a product title, because it may be protected as a trademark for a particular category of goods.