After my experience with cheap shower curtain rings, I thought the problem was the low selling price. I had earned nothing and had no room to adjust the price. I needed a more expensive, premium product with enough margin for advertising and marketing.
I opened the analytics software again and searched for products priced above $20. I found a growing market for travel neck pillows, the curved ones people use on planes and buses. Almost all the pillows on Amazon were black. The data showed that people were searching for and buying blue ones, but there were few options. This was in 2014 or 2015.
I decided to make the ideal neck pillow. Instead of ordinary stuffing, I wanted special microbeads that would let it fit the shape of the neck. The fabric mattered most to me. I wanted a premium cover that felt lovely to touch, was hypoallergenic and had no plastic smell.
I went back to Alibaba and contacted 20 suppliers. Only five agreed to make a trial batch of 50 pillows. I ordered samples, tested how they felt and chose a manufacturer willing to meet my requirements and include a nice gift box in the price. I sent the first batch to an Amazon warehouse.
I set the price at around $24. The margin looked good, I started advertising and felt confident. Then I faced a reality that no analytics program had considered.
It turned out to be almost impossible to sell the feeling of quality through a screen. I knew my pillow was incredibly soft and comfortable. Buyers just saw another blue pillow that cost more than the competition. I hired a professional product photographer and had detailed photos taken to show the fabric texture.
I joined Amazon Vine and gave away pillows to get honest reviews. People praised the quality and gave five stars, but it did not solve the sales problem. Advertising ate the budget because conversion was low. It was hard to explain why buyers should pay more for fabric they could not touch.
I ordered another 200 pillows to build momentum, but sales remained difficult. That was when I saw the real problem. While I was choosing fabrics and running pillow ads, my wall decal business began to suffer. I had stopped creating new designs and following printing trends. My attention had shifted away from the business that supported me.
I realised I was chasing an imaginary gold mine while losing the real one. I sold all the pillows at break even to recover my money and stopped reselling Chinese products through Amazon FBA. I returned to my printers, started looking for new trends and designs again, and focused on making wall decals. The experience taught me that sometimes the best way to earn more is to develop what you already do well instead of searching for another niche.