Selling Albert Einstein wall decals through Decords taught me an expensive lesson about intellectual property. It cost me nerves and left a warning on my Etsy account. About three years ago, I noticed strong sales of products featuring his quotes, the famous photo with his tongue out and stylised portraits. I wanted to try the trend.
After earlier copyright problems, I knew I needed to check the rights first. I read about protection lasting 70 years after an author's death. Einstein died in 1955, and I mistakenly decided that his image was free to use. I had mixed up rights to an artwork with rights involving a person's name and likeness.
I drew a vector portrait, turned it into a wall decal and listed it. Sales started almost immediately, and I thought I had found a bestseller. A couple of months later, I received an official trademark complaint. How could the name of someone who died over half a century ago be a registered brand?
That was how I learned about the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, which inherited Einstein's archives and literary estate. The university also licenses commercial uses of his name and likeness and protects its trademarks. An application for one US Albert Einstein registration was filed in 2003, and the mark was registered in 2009. Its goods included printed products.
I had missed the difference between copyright terms and trademark protection. A photograph's copyright term is not calculated from the death of the person in it. A trademark does not ban every mention of a name or every portrait either. The particular image, its use and the applicable rules matter.
I tried to settle things peacefully and wrote to the rights holders. I admitted that I had misunderstood the rights, apologised and removed the listing everywhere. I hoped they would withdraw the complaint so it would not remain on the shop's record.
The reply was cold and professional. They accepted the apology but refused to withdraw the complaint. They told me I would need an official licence to continue those sales. When I saw the price, I realised that even ten years of selling those decals would not cover half of it.
The warning stayed on my account. The matter never reached court because I stopped selling immediately. My lesson was that a famous person's date of death cannot settle the rights question on its own. Now I check rights to the specific image and possible restrictions on commercial use of the name separately.